Cloudy 55°5 Day Forecast
Home : Ames Tribune : OPINION : Letters to the Editor
  • Featured Today
    • Midlands Auction Network
    • Business Monthly: January 2009
    • Facets: January 2009
    • Mid-Iowa Worship
    • Job Network
    • Online calendar
  • Entertainment
    • Arts & entertainment
    • Taste
    • Crossword
  • Multi-media galleries
    • News videos
    • 2008: Year in review
    • News
    • Features
    • Sports
    • Class of 2008
  • About People
    • All categories
    • Celebrations, Announcements
    • School News
    • Senior News
    • Volunteers, Service Clubs
    • Recognition, Awards
    • Columns
    • Events
  • Mid-Iowa news sites
    • Ames Tribune
    • Boone News-Republican
    • Dallas County News
    • Nevada Journal
    • Tri-County Times
    • AgNet: Farm & ranch news
    • Midlands Auction Network
    • Mid-Iowa Homefinder - real estate guide
    • Mid-Iowa for Sale by Owner - real estate
  • Mid-Iowa Resources
    • Community links
    • Community sites
    • Mid-Iowa Worship
    • Visit Mid-Iowa
    • Legals & notices
    • Mid-Iowa for Sale by Owner - real estate
    • Business Directory
  • Subscribe
    • Start paper delivery
    • Order gift subscription
    • New delivery address
    • Vacation Stop/Start
  • Submit Info
    • Anniversaries
    • Births
    • Calendar item
    • Engagements
    • Letter to the editor
    • Press releases
    • Weddings
  • Contests & promotions
    • Big Holiday Giveaway
    • Bridal ExCYtement
    • Find the best gas prices
    • Vintage Vehicles
Top newspaper ads
Paramedic, RN, & Housekeeper needed CNA, Exemplary Nurse, Domestic Aids, Dietary Aids View All
Top Jobs
Top Homes
Top Rentals
Letters to the Editor
Counterfeit science
By: John W. Patterson, 3603 Woodland St., Ames
07/06/2005
Updated 07/14/2005 02:06:19 AM CDT
email this storyEmail to a friendpost a commentPost a Commentprinter friendlyPrinter-friendly
To the Editor

"The Privileged Planet," a book by Guillermo Gonzalez (assistant professor of physics at Iowa State University) and Jay W. Richards (theologian with the Seattle-based Center for the Renewal of Science and Culture) is (in the writer's opinion) easily the most significant book of counterfeit science I have read in the last decade.
      Both authors have long been active in the so-called Wedge movement of creationists who are infuriated that science no longer admits supernatural or God-based explanations of any kind, nor even any Intelligent Design arguments, such as were first popularized by the 19th century Anglican theologian, William Paley.
      To those ignorant of the history and logic of modern science, the Intelligent Design arguments and inferences championed in "The Privileged Planet" will seem scientifically sound, even compelling. But the book is religious apologetics from beginning to end, not science at all. And yet it is marketed as a popularly written science book based on the latest findings of astronomy and physics.
      I bought a "signed" first edition at Iowa State's University Bookstore more than a year ago. I promptly read it cover to cover and then wrote and circulated a review replete with poignant criticisms too extensive to include here. Recently, however, the Wedge movement has produced a movie based on the book and hopes to screen it in churches, high schools, colleges, science centers and other venues across the U. S. So much controversy erupted when the Smithsonian recently co-sponsored a screening, that the Institution promptly withdrew from the co-sponsorship agreement.
      For details on the origin and history the Wedge movement, interested readers should consult "Creationism's Trojan Horse: The Wedge of Intelligent Design," by philosophy professor Barbara Forrest and investigative journalist Paul R. Gross (Oxford University Press, 2004).
      In addition to identifying the Wedge's most prominent leaders and activists, the book also identifies many of the wealthy backers - foundations and individuals - that have enabled ID/Wedge creationists to market their views as science, despite the scientific poverty of their claims. Of these, perhaps multi-billionaire Howard Fieldstead Ahmanson, Jr., is the most appropriate one to mention here.
      First of all, Howard married a central Iowan, the former Roberta Green of Perry. Thanks to her (and Howard's money, presumably) the Hotel Pattee among other buildings in Perry have enjoyed some rather spectacular renovations. Secondly, it was Howard and Roberta who donated crucial seed money to help launch the Wedge movement back in the 1990s.
      Finally, in past decades, Howard Jr., donated generously to the Christian Reconstructionists, back when the late Rousas John Rushdoony led that movement. It was during those years that Howard served - some two decades, I believe - on the board of their think tank, The Chalcedon Foundation.
      Why is this relevant? Because the agenda of the Reconstructionists, according to the Chalcedon Foundation journal, was then, and remains now, that of remaking the U. S. into a Christian Theocracy: one that would be governed not by democracy (which they regard as heresy) but by a radical form of Old Testament biblical law.
      Though far from being as violent, the Reconstructionists seem to have in mind for Christianity and the U. S. what the Taliban did for Islam and Afghanistan.


©Mid-Iowa Newspapers 2013

Submit your comment now
Comment Title:
Submit your comments on the article in the space below:
Your Name: Click here to register or login. (required)
What's This?
In order to verify you are not a spam-bot you will need to use the image above.
The addition of the flashing numbers above =
By submitting your comment, you acknowledge that you have read and accept the Terms and Conditions of this site.

email this storyEmail to a friendpost a commentPost a Commentprinter friendlyPrinter-friendlyTop
Online Forms
Classifieds
Print Subscribers
    * Start a New Subscription
    * Order a Gift Subscription
    * Change Delivery Address
    * Vacation Stop/Start
Submit Announcements
    * Anniversaries
    * Births
    * Engagements
    * Weddings
Submit Letters/Opinions
    * Letter to the Editor
    * Press Release
Online Forms
    * Contact our staff
Contact Us
Street Address and P.O. Box

The Tribune
P.O. Box 380
317 Fifth St.
Ames, Iowa 50010

Primary Telephone/Fax Numbers

(800) 234-TRIB
(515) 663-6900
Fax: (515) 232-2364

Other Telephone/Fax Numbers

Business Office Fax: (515) 232-7935

Mid-Iowa news Web sites

* Algona Upper Des Moines
* Ames Tribune
* Dallas County News
* Boone News Republican
* Go Cyclones!
* Mid-Iowa News
* Nevada Journal
* Tri-County Times
* agNET
* feeds
* Daily updates by e-mail


Quick Archive Search

advanced search  
© 2010 Iowa Newspapers, Inc. All rights reserved.

Terms of Service | Copyright | Privacy