Partly cloudy 75°5 Day Forecast
Home : Ames Tribune : OPINION : Columnists
  • Featured Today
    • Midlands Auction Network
    • Business Monthly: January 2009
    • Facets: January 2009
    • Mid-Iowa Worship
    • Job Network
    • Online calendar
  • Entertainment
    • Arts & entertainment
    • Taste
    • Crossword
  • Multi-media galleries
    • News videos
    • 2008: Year in review
    • News
    • Features
    • Sports
    • Class of 2008
  • About People
    • All categories
    • Celebrations, Announcements
    • School News
    • Senior News
    • Volunteers, Service Clubs
    • Recognition, Awards
    • Columns
    • Events
  • Mid-Iowa news sites
    • Algona Upper Des Moines
    • Ames Tribune
    • Boone News-Republican
    • Dallas County News
    • Go Cyclones!
    • Nevada Journal
    • Tri-County Times
    • AgNet: Farm & ranch news
    • Midlands Auction Network
    • Mid-Iowa Homefinder - real estate guide
    • Mid-Iowa for Sale by Owner - real estate
  • Mid-Iowa Resources
    • Community links
    • Community sites
    • Mid-Iowa Worship
    • Visit Mid-Iowa
    • Legals & notices
    • Mid-Iowa Homefinder
    • Mid-Iowa for Sale by Owner - real estate
    • Business Directory
  • Subscribe
    • Start paper delivery
    • Order gift subscription
    • New delivery address
    • Vacation Stop/Start
  • Submit Info
    • Anniversaries
    • Births
    • Calendar item
    • Engagements
    • Letter to the editor
    • Press releases
    • Weddings
  • Contests & promotions
    • Big Holiday Giveaway
    • Bridal ExCYtement
    • Find the best gas prices
    • Vintage Vehicles
Top newspaper ads
Paramedic, RN, & Housekeeper needed CNA, Exemplary Nurse, Domestic Aids, Dietary Aids View All
Top Jobs
Top Homes
Top Rentals
Columnists
Dick Haws: It's a black and white issue
12/02/2007
Updated 12/10/2007 12:06:05 AM CST
email this storyEmail to a friendpost a commentPost a Commentprinter friendlyPrinter-friendly
Despite the reluctance of too many speakers to be frank, it seemed to me the issue Ames began to address Tuesday night at City Hall came down to this - the relationship between black people and white people. It's that simple.

This was obviously the crux of the matter, because I didn't hear any Hispanic people telling the overflow crowd about problems they were having in Ames. Nor did I hear any Asian people nor any American Indians speaking out. No, the only people I heard detail complaints about the police and the schools were Ames black people.

To be sure, black people have long lived in Ames, but typically, they were pretty well integrated into our town, largely because they were highly educated and held good jobs. That didn't mean they didn't suffer because of their race. I still vividly remember a black woman with a doctorate telling me she'd never again walk through Campustown after dark because of the names she'd been called by the drunken Billy Bobs.

But the problem today is more than that. It's also related to class. Many of the new-arriving black people are poor, not highly educated, refugees from the inner city.

Some of what we heard Tuesday was enough to break your heart, like stories from black people who said they had come to Ames to start a new life but doubted it would be possible now because of what they considered police harassment.

The hearing suggested the community upset could be traced to two main sources - the vicious crimes, including two murders, that occurred recently, and the difficulty the Ames schools are having in dealing with these new black students.

First to the crimes. Because black people have been implicated in several of these crimes, police apparently have been monitoring a number of these new arrivals closely. Police Chief Chuck Cychosz took some heavy criticism from several speakers, including one young black man who said he was so disillusioned by police, he wouldn't trust any Ames police officer to investigate his complaint of harassment.

The young man obviously wants his criticism to be addressed in another venue, which is something the mayor and City Council need to pay attention to if they expect to have much credibility with such people. Remember 2004. In the weary aftermath of yet another Veishea riot, then-Chief Loras Jaeger asked the Iowa Attorney General to make an independent review of charges of overreaction by police. The AG's conclusion? No prosecution of any police officer was warranted. Maybe we again need the help of another outside expert.

And then we get to the schools. Speaker after speaker told of their children coming home with reports they'd been called the "n" word by other students in the hallways of Ames schools. One mother said that even her 5-year-old daughter had faced it. But one rumor that wasn't discussed but has circulated throughout the community suggests that some of these newly arrived black students are more than difficult to deal with.

Defenders of these students respond that it's simply because they are different.

It reminded me of the year I spent teaching in a junior high school in New York City's Harlem, just down the street from the Apollo Theater. It was way back in 1968. I had been hired by the New York City Schools because they believed that because I had taught black students in Africa as a Peace Corps volunteer, I could do the same in their junior high school.

But I quickly realized this was different, that I'd be lucky to keep my head above water. I did notice, however, a tiny, old black teacher whose classroom was just down the hallway from me. She never had a problem. Students would come boiling out of my classroom and enter hers, quiet as church mice. I went to find out the reason.

She said she'd been teaching in that junior high school for something like 30-plus years, that she had taught many of her students' parents, their aunts and uncles, their older brothers and sisters, that she lived in Harlem among her students, that she saw them on the street, in the stores, in church. She also knew about me, that I was a stranger in Harlem, that she'd bet I wouldn't finish the year, that I didn't live in Harlem, that I didn't shop in the neighborhood, that I didn't walk Harlem streets, that I didn't attend a Harlem church.

She was an institution in that school, and every student knew it and behaved accordingly. I, on the other hand, was an outsider.

My first semester there was a trial by ordeal. But as the first semester was ending, those students saw - surprisingly, I think - that I was still there, and their behavior started to improve.

By the middle of the second semester, I have to confess, I even was beginning to enjoy the experience, and I think the students were too. But they also were betting I wouldn't come back because so many of their other teachers hadn't.

In the end, the students were right about me, because as soon as the school year ended, I was off to graduate school, never to return.

After listening to all the comments at Ames City Hall Tuesday, I'm certain only of this - race relations still are the most intractable problem this country faces. I just don't think Ames can give up.

Dick Haws taught journalism at Iowa State University for 21 years. He can be reached at dhaws@iastate.edu.


©Mid-Iowa Newspapers 2010

Submit your comment now
Comment Title:
Submit your comments on the article in the space below:
Your Name: Click here to register or login. (required)
What's This?
In order to verify you are not a spam-bot you will need to use the image above.
The addition of the flashing numbers above =
By submitting your comment, you acknowledge that you have read and accept the Terms and Conditions of this site.

email this storyEmail to a friendpost a commentPost a Commentprinter friendlyPrinter-friendlyTop
Online Forms
Classifieds
Print Subscribers
    * Start a New Subscription
    * Order a Gift Subscription
    * Change Delivery Address
    * Vacation Stop/Start
Submit Announcements
    * Anniversaries
    * Births
    * Engagements
    * Weddings
Submit Letters/Opinions
    * Letter to the Editor
    * Press Release
Online Forms
    * Contact our staff
Contact Us
Street Address and P.O. Box

The Tribune
P.O. Box 380
317 Fifth St.
Ames, Iowa 50010

Primary Telephone/Fax Numbers

(800) 234-TRIB
(515) 663-6900
Fax: (515) 232-2364

Other Telephone/Fax Numbers

Business Office Fax: (515) 232-7935

Mid-Iowa news Web sites

* Algona Upper Des Moines
* Ames Tribune
* Dallas County News
* Boone News Republican
* Go Cyclones!
* Mid-Iowa News
* Nevada Journal
* Tri-County Times
* agNET
* feeds
* Daily updates by e-mail


Quick Archive Search

advanced search  
© 2010 Iowa Newspapers, Inc. All rights reserved.

Terms of Service | Copyright | Privacy