Partly cloudy 51°5 Day Forecast
Home : Ames Tribune : OPINION : Editorials
  • Featured Today
    • Midlands Auction Network
    • Business Monthly: January 2009
    • Facets: January 2009
    • Mid-Iowa Worship
    • Job Network
    • Online calendar
  • Entertainment
    • Arts & entertainment
    • Taste
    • Crossword
  • Multi-media galleries
    • News videos
    • 2008: Year in review
    • News
    • Features
    • Sports
    • Class of 2008
  • About People
    • All categories
    • Celebrations, Announcements
    • School News
    • Senior News
    • Volunteers, Service Clubs
    • Recognition, Awards
    • Columns
    • Events
  • Mid-Iowa news sites
    • Algona Upper Des Moines
    • Ames Tribune
    • Boone News-Republican
    • Dallas County News
    • Go Cyclones!
    • Nevada Journal
    • Tri-County Times
    • AgNet: Farm & ranch news
    • Midlands Auction Network
    • Mid-Iowa Homefinder - real estate guide
    • Mid-Iowa for Sale by Owner - real estate
  • Mid-Iowa Resources
    • Community links
    • Community sites
    • Mid-Iowa Worship
    • Visit Mid-Iowa
    • Legals & notices
    • Mid-Iowa Homefinder
    • Mid-Iowa for Sale by Owner - real estate
    • Business Directory
  • Subscribe
    • Start paper delivery
    • Order gift subscription
    • New delivery address
    • Vacation Stop/Start
  • Submit Info
    • Anniversaries
    • Births
    • Calendar item
    • Engagements
    • Letter to the editor
    • Press releases
    • Weddings
  • Contests & promotions
    • Big Holiday Giveaway
    • Bridal ExCYtement
    • Find the best gas prices
    • Vintage Vehicles
Top newspaper ads
Paramedic, RN, & Housekeeper needed CNA, Exemplary Nurse, Domestic Aids, Dietary Aids View All
Top Jobs
Top Homes
Top Rentals
Editorials
Back room politics prevail
12/27/2007
Updated 01/04/2008 12:06:03 AM CST
email this storyEmail to a friendpost a commentPost a Commentprinter friendlyPrinter-friendly
Barack Obama blames lobbyists. Hunger and environmental groups blame Democratic leaders. Sen. Chuck Grassley calls it "smearing lipstick on a pig." The federal farm bill passed by the Senate was a turkey delivered for the holidays. It won't get much better when it is recooked in conference committee when Congress reconvenes.

This bill in both its Senate and House versions will continue to pump millions of subsidies into the pockets of wealthy landowners already earning record prices for crops. The abuse is epitomized by anecdotes such as a California property owner in the 90210 zip code who receives $1 million in subsidies for crops on land he doesn't set foot on. The statistics back up the stories. Seventy-three percent of payments are pocketed by 10 percent of the recipients, Grassley says.

The bills that will be worked out continue price supports for major commodity crops, corn, soybeans, cotton, wheat and rice. Backers argue that new measures promote biofuels and help fruit and vegetable growers. But the basic structure of the farm bill is unchanged.

You might think that this would be a classic "Eat The Rich" argument between Republicans and Democrats. But in fact, the Democratic leadership in Congress failed to change the structure that pumps millions into the wealthiest of those who call themselves farmers. It further erodes the dwindling culture of the family farmer.

Bipartisan groups of representatives and senators did attempt to limit payments to the top tier in various ways, including Grassley and Sen. Byron Dorgan (D-North Dakota). The Washington Post counted four major efforts to change the bill's subsidy system and to shift dollars into conservation and nutrition programs.

But in the end, back room politics prevailed. Senators from the Midwest and South banded to defeat the amendments. Sen. Blanche Lincoln, D-Ark., who supports subsidies, threatened a filibuster if the Senate did not require a 60-vote minimum on the amendments. To save face on a potential filibuster in their own ranks, Democratic leadership gave in and the Grassley-Dorgan cap was defeated even though it received a majority of support.

And that's why Obama can blame influential lobbyists, and why advocacy groups can blame leadership.

Calling it a farm bill at all is a misnomer. Two thirds of the bill has to do with food stamps and nutrition programs. Crop subsidies, which are the major bone of contention, are a lesser part.

We were encouraged early in the campaign when Hillary Clinton, responding to a forum, indicated she might be willing to consider renaming it something like the rural America bill to more accurately reflect its mission, and thereby change direction. But that idea seems to have died in the campaigning.

Here is where Iowa might have truly led the nation. By pushing harder to revise a federal program that everyone agrees is an abuse, real change might have been effected.

As party members go to caucus next week, some ought to think about how their choices could make a difference.


©Mid-Iowa Newspapers 2009

Submit your comment now
Comment Title:
Submit your comments on the article in the space below:
Your Name: Click here to register or login. (required)
What's This?
In order to verify you are not a spam-bot you will need to use the image above.
The addition of the flashing numbers above =
By submitting your comment, you acknowledge that you have read and accept the Terms and Conditions of this site.
Reader Comments
Added: Saturday December 29, 2007 at 07:23 PM EST
Ilegal Drugs
It is important for American families in this Presidential debate, that the candidates point out their plans to eradicate the illegal drug consumption. It is alarming the hallucinogenic doing everywhere, surpassing the 200 billion dollars a year. We all most been informed reading books like “The Dope Runner” that tell us how the drug cartels operate creating corruption and death all over.
Al Porter, Long Beach, CA

email this storyEmail to a friendpost a commentPost a Commentprinter friendlyPrinter-friendlyTop
Online Forms
Classifieds
Print Subscribers
    * Start a New Subscription
    * Order a Gift Subscription
    * Change Delivery Address
    * Vacation Stop/Start
Submit Announcements
    * Anniversaries
    * Births
    * Engagements
    * Weddings
Submit Letters/Opinions
    * Letter to the Editor
    * Press Release
Online Forms
    * Contact our staff
Contact Us
Street Address and P.O. Box

The Tribune
P.O. Box 380
317 Fifth St.
Ames, Iowa 50010

Primary Telephone/Fax Numbers

(800) 234-TRIB
(515) 663-6900
Fax: (515) 232-2364

Other Telephone/Fax Numbers

Business Office Fax: (515) 232-7935

Mid-Iowa news Web sites

* Algona Upper Des Moines
* Ames Tribune
* Dallas County News
* Boone News Republican
* Go Cyclones!
* Mid-Iowa News
* Nevada Journal
* Tri-County Times
* agNET
* feeds
* Daily updates by e-mail


Quick Archive Search

advanced search  
© 2009 Iowa Newspapers, Inc. All rights reserved.

Terms of Service | Copyright | Privacy